Wuchak
December 11, 2022**_Legalism and naïveté threaten to destroy a family in a Texas town_**
The daughter (Andrea Bowen) of the pastor of a small town in east Texas (Ron Jackson) comes home after several years in Houston living a wayward life with her drug-dealing beau. She reflects on the chain of events that led to her destructive course and tries to put the pieces back together.
"The Preacherâs Daughterâ (2012) is an Indie drama that was picked up by Lifetime and aired with the cussing bleeped out and one or two edgy scenes trimmed. Thankfully, the uncensored version is readily available. The story is similar to the obscure and underrated "Beyond the Farthest Star" (2013), but arguably better. While not autobiographical, you can tell writer/director Michelle Mower grew up as a pastorâs daughter because everythingâs so real.
Mower doesnât make the mistake of making a certain character frothing at the mouth with ee-vil. Heâs basically a decent man, but he has carnal weaknesses and itâs a slow spiral into hell. What goes down shouldâve never happened in the first place. Anyone with common sense knows you donât put a nubile young female in a situation where sheâs alone with a handsome older male for long periods of time. Itâs literally asking for trouble. The first step in resisting temptation is to not unnecessarily be put into a place of temptation in the first place.
Someone criticized the film as âanti-Christian,â but itâs not. Itâs anti-legalism and anti-naĂŻvetĂ©, not to mention anti-hypocrisy. One issue is the stifling over-protection of well-meaning parents. Rachel (Jamie Teer) insightfully points out that she didnât know what was worse, having parents who care too much or ones who donât give a hoot at all. Both extremes are not good, but at least with parents who are overprotective their motivation is usually love⊠and love is the only thing that can overcome the shackles of legalism or libertinism (which are two sides of the same bad coin).
There are little gems of insights interspersed throughout, like the irony of the âbadâ girl being a virgin and the folly of making rash judgments.
But doesnât the overt cussing by a few characters and the sex scene make this an anti-Christian movie? No, it makes it realistic. After all, people cuss in real life every day, including many Christians. Iâm not saying itâs good, just that itâs the way it is. Thankfully, itâs arguably not overdone, which is similar to the way a bit oâ cussing was included in âJohn, 316â (2020).
As for the sex scene (which isnât very explicit), doesnât the Bible itself chronicle such scenes, like David & Bathsheba, not to mention Lotâs daughters? What about Judah and his daughter-in-law in Genesis 38? Accounts like these depict life in a fallen world, nothing more, nothing less.
One critic said that the filmâs too tame for non-Christian viewers, but if it were any edgier youâd have the hopeless melancholy of âGardens of the Nightâ (2008).
The ending leaves some things up in the air, but isnât that the way it is in real life? This is a slice-of-life in Hannahâs spiritual sojourn. If sheâs wise, thereâs no where to go but up. Yet that has to do with her NEXT chapter.
The film runs 1 hour, 47 minutes, and was shot in Alvin, Texas, which is just south of Houston, with some scenes done in the big city.
GRADE: A/A-